In these difficult economic times,
communities just like yours are looking for the key advantage that will make
them stand out from the crowd. As you look for that competitive edge in the
challenging world of economic development, consider becoming a leader in
health information exchange (HIE). This just may be the unique advantage you
need to distinguish your community from your competition. As an added plus,
the cost is relatively low and the benefits extraordinarily high.
In 2004, President Bush signed an order
that each person in the United States will have a personal health record by
2014. Although HIE development has been in process for several years, this
Executive Order can be seen as the beginning point in the transformation of
healthcare delivery in the United States. HIE activity is taking place in
many states. Corporate giants such as Microsoft and Google are now
introducing personal health records for consumers. It is simply a matter of
time before consumers, instead of payers, are directly participating in, if
not controlling their own health care. At that point the entire system
becomes consumer/patient-centric. As with any transformative process, the
early adopters will gain the most benefits and have the greatest ability to
shape their own future.
Today, only six percent of our healthcare
providers are fully electronic. In other words, your medical records are
still being done as they were one hundred years ago, in paper and ink. It
doesn’t matter if it’s your primary care physician, your local hospital, or
your pharmacy. Your medical records are being kept on a piece of paper and
stored in a file at each of your provider locations.
In addition, your lab results are being
photocopied and faxed from your lab to your doctor, your medical records are
not accessible to you if you go on vacation outside your community, and the
odds are good they contain some incorrect information. If a disaster like
Katrina strikes, your medical records may be lost forever. If you have an
emergency, even near your home, odds are that your medical records will not
be available at the emergency room when you arrive. Critical time will be
lost simply because your provider still uses paper and pencil. The time to
change this dangerous situation is now.
In addition, we are all concerned with
homeland security today and how our communities may respond in dealing with
a variety of medical crises/events that could potentially occur. In
controlling the rapid spread of a contagious disease and/or dealing with
bioterrorism, immediate access to key information is critical to a quick and
decisive response. HIE provides exactly the type of speed and accuracy
demanded by the consumer in any public health crisis.
In the future you will have your health
information, correct, complete, and current, and available to you and your
healthcare provider, when and where you need it so you can receive the best
possible care. A simple vision of the future, but one that is extremely
difficult to achieve. Today, it is nearly impossible to electronically
transfer your records from where they are to where they are needed. HIE can
change all of that and give your community a key competitive advantage.
1. What is HIE?
HIE is simply the transmission and receipt
of health information electronically. It makes your health information
available to you and your providers when and where you need it so you can
receive the best possible care.
• Health Information Exchange is a key
part of the solution of moving healthcare into the 21st century. It
consists of two primary components.
First is the use of technology to support
organizational practice and clinical requirements, including Electronic
Medical Records (EMR’s), Practice Management Systems, and E-prescribing.
The second component is the infrastructure
to enable data sharing between organizations.
• Recent studies indicate over 98,000
patients die each year due to clerical medical errors and more than
1,000,000 serious medication errors occur annually. The United States
spends nearly twice as much per capita as any other nation and still
ranks only 37th in the developed world in overall healthcare quality.
2. How does HIE work?
It works the way other electronic systems
such as banking and e-commerce work in our world today. Your medical records
and history are captured electronically and transmitted to the providers
that need the information to supply you with the care your need where you
need it. The best analogy is to compare your medical records to your banking
records. We can all stop by an ATM almost anywhere in the world and access
cash from our bank. Our money is available to us when and where we need it.
Unfortunately, that is not true of your medical records in the absence of
HIE.
3. Why HIE?
HIE is a low cost, high return opportunity
to make your community more attractive for economic development. Whether you
are looking to attract new business to the community or grow and retain
existing businesses, HIE gives you the advantage you need to be more
competitive.
• In nearly every survey of “Great
Places to Live/Work”, the quality and availability of medical care is
one of the key factors in rating and comparing communities. The ability
to attract and retain the best and the brightest employers and employees
in any community is a distinct advantage and will lead to higher
ratings. Companies that are looking to relocate or expand consider this
factor in choosing their new community. HIE is one major tool for
upgrading the quality of care in any community.
• Recent studies have estimated that
$100 billion per year is spent on redundant treatments and mistakes.
Given the rapid rise in healthcare expenditures (15% of GDP rising to
19% by 2015), HIE can deliver better accuracy for lower costs and help
restrain the growth of healthcare expense for everyone. Some of the
efficiencies gained from HIE include:
-
Patients can get enhanced services
through e-visits, reminders, scheduling, prescription refills, and
many other services now requiring timely and costly provider visits.
-
Patients and providers can receive
their lab and imaging results online for real-time care and greater
efficiency.
-
Patients and providers have new
capabilities to collaborate with shared case management tools,
identification of best practices and consultation with experts
worldwide.
• The ability to recruit the best and
the brightest providers leads to higher quality healthcare. Both primary
and acute care providers prefer to be in an environment where they can
interact with and have access to specialists with a variety of skills
and competencies. When a community has good healthcare provider talent,
it will tend to attract more and better healthcare provider talent.
Having more provider capabilities in a community gives that community
the ability to provide better health care. Success breeds success.
• The ability to attract and retain
the best providers is critical. Recent medical school graduates are
already HIE competent when they enter the workforce and have an
expectation of operating in an electronic environment. Communities that
are well along the HIE path have a clear advantage when recruiting the
highest quality providers to their community.
4. Economic Growth Tool
There are three primary reasons HIE is
such an attractive tool for communities looking for that competitive edge:
• Better quality healthcare
In addition to the benefits of being able
to attract better physicians and reducing medical errors, HIE increases the
quality of care for the community. Consumers are increasingly aware of
communities that can provide them with the highest quality healthcare and
will choose to live in communities based on the ability of the community to
provide their desired level of service. In addition, communities adopting
HIE can look forward to an electronic future where they can connect with
patients in a variety of new ways and offer a variety of new services.
• Lower overall healthcare costs
Numerous studies indicate significant
savings can be obtained by all of the providers and users of healthcare. As
healthcare consumes an ever increasing portion of our GDP, anything that
reduces this growth of expense will be a real attractor for companies
seeking the community that can provide the best healthcare at the lowest
cost.
Even a percentage point or two in lower
costs can add up to millions of dollars for major corporations.
• Better responsiveness to a medical
crisis Government has a critical role to play in dealing with a variety of
medical crises/events that may occur in any community. In controlling the
rapid spread of a contagious disease and/or dealing with bioterrorism,
immediate access to key information is critical to a quick and decisive
local response. HIE provides exactly the type of speed and accuracy needed
to respond to a public health crisis.
5. Service to Local Employers
It is reasonable to expect employers will
enjoy the benefits of lower healthcare costs based on the improvements
brought about by HIE. HIE has been shown to reduce the overall costs of
healthcare. Lower healthcare costs will eventually result in lower
healthcare premium costs to employers and employees. Employers, one of the
main funders of the healthcare system, will see a direct correlation between
their costs and improvements in care.
HIE also provides a critical tool for
improved healthcare for all consumers/patients. These improvements in the
quality and delivery of healthcare in a community will result in an overall
improvement in the general health of the population. Employers directly
benefit by having healthier employees who are more productive, lose less
time to illness, and have higher morale.
In addition, HIE is an advantage to the
employers who participate in HIE. Younger workers entering the
workforce have very high expectations concerning control over their
healthcare information. They are capable of using HIE to promote healthier
lifestyles and to gain control over their own healthcare. Employers that can
provide HIE for their employees will have an advantage when it comes to
recruiting and retaining top level talent.
6. Why Economic Development?
Economic Development entities have
distinct advantages over any other potential organizations in your community
to be the catalyst to for HIE. These advantages include:
• Community Leadership
In most communities, most of the key local
leaders are an integral part of the economic development effort. It is
unlikely that all of these key players are part of any other local
organization. Therefore, it is natural for economic development to assume
this role.
• Vested Interest
These same community leaders also
represent most of the major employers, government leaders, and healthcare
providers in the community. As discussed above, everyone stands to gain from
HIE. In several communities across the country, employers are beginning to
take the lead in pushing HIE in their community simply because they see the
benefits that accrue directly to them. In other communities, government
officials are taking the lead. However, the best solution is when they all
work together.
• Independent Third Party
As with any project that impacts numerous
local entities, there is concern about the impact the change may have on
each individual entity. When the conversion to HIE is led by one of the
entities with a vested interest, trust instantly becomes an issue.
Regardless on the motivation, even if it is totally pure, others will be
suspicious and resistant. The local economic development agency has the
advantage of being viewed as a generally neutral party. This neutrality
positions economic development as the natural leader for the HIE effort.
7. How Do I Get Started?
There are four simple steps you can take
immediately to begin the journey to HIE in your community.
• Step 1 is to learn as much about HIE
as possible. There are numerous sources of information on the subject.
(See the attached for a partial list of web resources.)
• Step 2 is to craft a detailed
strategy and plan for introducing HIE into your community by leveraging
the organizations included in your membership. The key to your strategy
is the identification of the value proposition for each member of your
organization to be an active participant in the project.
• Step 3 is to obtain the support and
commitment from your Board of Directors for implementing your HIE
strategy.
• Step 4 is to build community support
for the project. This step involves a general education process as well
as individual meetings with key potential constituents to gain a wide
basis of support for your efforts. Once you get the community
behind you, HIE will take off and you will begin to see the rewards from
your work, and your community will be much more competitive in the
challenging world of economic development.